If a tree falls in the forest, does Pakistan have any liberals?

Declan Walsh provides superb background on the social and religious inequities, marginalisation and oppression historically suffered by Pakistan’s Ahmadi community.

He presses home a point that I made here. On the complete silence that followed the massacre of more than 100 Ahmadi worshippers in 2 mosques in Lahore, in contrast to the “tsunami of outrage” of the Israeli flotilla attack.

The apathy and reticence displayed by Pakistan’s so-called “liberal elites” shows a lack of humanity that is downright repugnant. But given their silence, Walsh makes a valid point about their numbers. It raises the question, based on a famous ethical conundrum: If 100+ Ahmadi muslims are murdered in cold blood and Pakistan’s liberals do not make a noise, are there any liberals in Pakistan to speak of, at all?

Posted in Freedom of Religion, Human Rights | 7 Comments

Beyond the pale

An Egyptian lawyer argues for the right of Arab men to sexually harass Israeli women.

Posted in Israel/Palestine, Misogyny | 4 Comments

Is DCLG’s Senior Muslim Advisor Mohammad Abdul Aziz an Islamist Supporter?

This is a guest post by a brother from East London

Mohammad Abdul Aziz is a Senior Muslim Advisor at DCLG. He is also a honorary trustee of East London mosque (ELM) and the London Muslim Centre (LMC), as well as having been an advisor to the MCB. He was formerly an executive committee member of YMO, which is the youth wing of Islamic Forum of Europe (IFE) – an Islamist entryist group. After spending years in YMO propagating the teachings of the Islamist ideologue Maulana Mawdudi, Mohammad Aziz resigned to follow a stricter and more conservative form of Islam known as ‘Salafism’.

Mohammad Abdul Aziz

Posted in Islamism, UK Politics | 10 Comments

Egyptian Apartheid

Certain ideologues of the left who have appointed themselves as ‘Custodians for the Protection of Muslims’ (CPMs) would have us believe that Israel is the last outpost of apartheid. Take a look at Pickled Politics, Socialist (dis)Unity and the ever reliable Islamophobia-Watch, for a few examples.

But look at this new law passed in Egypt:

CAIRO — Egypt’s Supreme Administrative Court upheld a ruling on Saturday, that orders the country’s Interior Ministry to strip citizenship from Egyptians married to Israeli women.

The court said that the Interior Ministry should present each marriage case to the Cabinet on an individual basis. The Cabinet will then rule on whether to strip the Egyptian of his citizenship, taking into consideration whether a man married an Israeli Arab or a Jew when making its decision to revoke citizenship.

Posted in Antisemitism | 2 Comments

The Reactionary Public

To an outsider, Pakistan’s perceptions of its own political history appears to be mired in a culture of ‘whataboutery’, denial and deflection. So it is encouraging to read the occasional piece by Pakistani political commentator Nadeem Paracha because he does not patronise his readers with yet another analysis of Pakistan’s sectarian unrest by putting the blame on Zionists and US drone attacks. When it comes to talking truth to power, Paracha seems less affected by the culture of denial that afflicts most of his peers.

Here’s Paracha reflecting on how the military and the orthodox religious establishment of Pakistan have contributed and cultivated the heady mixture of nationalism, political Islamic extremism and sectarianism that currently assails Pakistan:

Here’s a question: How come whenever there’s a drone attack (in which most of those killed generally are extremists), or a case of perceived obscenity or blasphemy surfaces, street corners are at once filled with burqa-clad women and bearded men chanting slogans like ‘Death to infidels’? But none of these fine, sensitive Muslims can be seen protesting when there’s an attack on innocent civilians – Ahmadis or others – by the extremists?

Posted in Islamism, Sectarianism | 1 Comment

In The Room The Women Come And Go

Via Shiraz Socialist, this is a cross-post by Max Dunbar


Via Sunny Hundal at Pickled Politics, I’ve come across an excellent piece by Gita Sahgal, recently fired by Amnesty for speaking out against its gushing promotion of Taliban enthusiast Moazzam Begg and his fundamentalist CagePrisoners phony human rights group. (Here is the whole sorry tale.)

Sunny doesn’t care for the article – which is not surprising, for smart women dissidents get a hard time from the left these days. Western feminism consists of complaining about Sex and the City 2 rather than international solidarity with women in appalling circumstances.

Yet Sahgal makes a couple of important points. The first is about priorities. The issue of possible hijab bans has been raised yet again. There are good arguments for and against the ban. As Ophelia says, it’s progress that Sarkozy has called the burqa what it is – an instrument of oppression – but we should hesitate to draft laws that specifically target immigrants and ethnic minorities. People should be able to dress how they choose.

Posted in Human Rights | 1 Comment

Turkish Deceit

Last week, Turkish Foreign Minister Ahmet Davutoglu gave the USA a stern lecture on its role in the Flotilla incident, and revelled in his own “with us or without us” moment:

“Psychologically, this attack is like 9/11 for Turkey. We expect full solidarity with us. It should not seem like a choice between Turkey and Israel. It should be a choice between right and wrong, between legal and illegal.”

That’s an impressive job of grandstanding by Davutoglu, but let’s not forget that in the “choice between right and wrong” and in the not so distant past, Turkey had few scruples when it leveraged its alliance with the US and Israeli security organisations to help them to track down and imprison the Kurdish leader Abdullah Ocalan.

Posted in International Affairs, Israel/Palestine | 12 Comments

Making it Easier for Guardian Readers to Look Good

So funny and so true, it hurts.

ISRAEL’S attack on a Palestinian aid ship will make it easier for Guardian readers to sound as if they know what they are talking about, it was claimed last night.

Experts warned Tel Aviv that every time it launches a seemingly unprovoked or disproportionate attack it allows at least 10,000 cretins to say something at a dinner party that everyone then agrees with.

Dr Martin Bishop, of the Institute for Studies, said: “Benjamin Netanyahu has to realise that his aggressive stance towards Hamas and Hezbollah is playing into the hands of some of the worst people in the world.

“I simply cannot sit through another dinner party with some speccie fucker spouting off about Israel while all the single, attractive women around the table stare at him like he was Martin Luther King.

Posted in Farce | 2 Comments

Coming Out as an atheist

This is a brave and thoughtful article in CiF by Alom Shaha. It is 2010, yet this is an account by a man born into a muslim family who is careful not to offend or disappoint family and friends by “coming out” as an atheist. This article will be very helpful to those muslims who cannot articulate this statement, not just because of the ridiculous ‘Law of Apostasy’ which has little chance of being applied in Britain, but because of the fear of severing the ties that bind.

Well done Mr Shaha.

I am an atheist. I imagine that the typical Cif belief reader may not think this is a particularly big deal, but it is for me, because I’m not just an atheist – I’m an apostate from Islam. Apparently there are people who would happily kill me for making such a statement. But I’m not expecting to be killed, or even threatened; despite what the BNP and certain elements of the press might want you to think, the overwhelming majority of Muslims are not rabid fundamentalists who respond with violence to every perceived slight.

Posted in Esoterica | 1 Comment

meanwhile, in israel…

with the flotilla imbroglio (or fiasco, if you prefer) in full swing, yours truly has just arrived back from the zionist entity, where numerous representatives of clan bananabrain continue to live as normal a life as one might expect in what hussein shobokshi of asharq al-awsat describes as “a state established on a lie based on a myth” – and he was chosen as one of the “global leaders for tomorrow” by the world economic forum in 1995, so 15 years later he must be therefore a global leader and not at all the sort of bloke to make wild accusations about a massacre of 60 people (oh, hang on, what am i saying?). i’ll write separately about the flotilla stuff when i have a moment, but i thought it might be interesting to put up a few insights that i think you’ll find interesting, based as they are on a visit on a ground and interacting with normal, sensible [well, members of my family at any rate], well-educated israelis as well as a range of other social observations.

Posted in Civil Rights, Democracy, Freedom of Religion, International Affairs, Israel/Palestine, Jewish Extremism, Politics | 13 Comments
  • Categories

  • Archives