Category Archives: Multiculturalism

the big society, riots and “spiral dynamics”

obviously, a great deal has been written about the riots to date and a great deal of predictable outpouring has also taken place. what i wanted to offer to this debate is, however, along more behavioural lines.

i have for some time been aware of the powerful analytical frameworks for bio-psycho-social systems developed by the american psychologist dr clare graves and systematised for practical application by don beck and chris cowan in the excellent book “spiral dynamics” (i’m not affiliated with anyone concerned, incidentally). at the risk of sounding like somewhat of a “fanboy”, as i believe it is called on teh interwebs, i am convinced it constitutes an important piece of intellectual real estate for the understanding of complex socio-political systems, particularly in behavioural terms.

Also posted in Activism, Blogosphere, Civil Rights, Communalism, Crime, Democracy, Education, Ethics, Exegesis, Human Rights, Identity Politics, Media, Misc, Moral relativism, Political Correctnes gone mad!, Politics, The Far Left, The Left, The Regressive Left, UK Politics | Leave a comment

more precision needed – and include me out!

from the excellent-but-ferocious ophelia benson at butterflies and wheels:

“More precision needed. There should be a stamp for that. MPN should be like LOL or TMI.”

i agree. what narks me somewhat (and no doubt there are all sorts of reasons why i am wrong about this) is that this is *precisely* what bothers me about statements about a) religious people and b) the tendentious-as-feck word “judeo-christian”.

“But there again – that’s a matter of fact, not something that can just be declared from the armchair as if it were self-evident. Are Muslims as “diverse” as any other group of people living in the UK? Are all groups living in the UK exactly as diverse as each other, neither more nor less? I don’t see why that would be the case. It’s certainly not impossible that there is something about Islam and/or the history of people who emigrate from majority-Muslim countries that makes Muslims as a group tend to be different from other people as groups, including being less “diverse.” That’s something to find out, not just to announce as a necessary truth. Or a sacred cow…”

Also posted in Anti Muslim bigotry, Antisemitism, Blogosphere, Freedom of Religion, Homophobia, Human Rights, Islamism, Jewish Extremism, Moral relativism | Leave a comment

is honest dialogue compatible with the exposure of dishonest dialogue?

we at the spittoon seem spend a lot of time both criticising people who appear to be disingenuous, swivel-eyed fundamentalist weasels and their stooges, as well as calling for honest, open-hearted dialogue and support for a stronger, more liberal society in which both jews and muslims have a role to play, not just as citizens, but as jews and muslims. we believe both in the robust defence of liberty and the principles of democracy as well as aspiring to a better, more peaceful future in which people of differing religions, cultures and points of view will be able to live together – call it a messianic vision, if you like, or even “roddenberry-lite”, but we don’t see why people can’t “sit under their vine and fig-tree, with nobody to make them afraid“.

Also posted in Activism, Anti Muslim bigotry, Antisemitism, Blogosphere, Civil Rights, Democracy, Entryism, Freedom of Religion, Human Rights, Identity Politics, Interfaith, Islamism, Jewish Extremism, Racism, UK Politics | 27 Comments

Fear and HOPE: English identity, faith, and race

Hope Not Hate publish a new report called Fear and HOPE, available for download tomorrow. The report is based on a Populus survey exploring the issues of English identity, faith, and race. The findings are not encouraging.

The executive summary explains the depressing downside:

On one level it is not happy reading. It concludes that there is not a progressive majority in society and it reveals that there is a deep resentment to immigration, as well as scepticism towards multiculturalism. There is a widespread fear of the ‘Other’, particularly Muslims, and there is an appetite for a new right-wing political party that has none of the fascist trappings of the British National Party or the violence of the English Defence League. With a clear correlation between economic pessimism and negative views to immigration, the situation is likely to get worse over the next few years.

The key findings of the report:

Also posted in Identity Politics, Immigration, UK Politics | Leave a comment

Mahfooz Kanwar: On Official Multiculturalism

Mahfooz Kanwar

"If you want to live under sharia law, go back to the hellhole country you came from, or go to another hellhole country that lives under sharia law," says Mahfooz Kanwar, a member of the Muslim Canadian Congress. (Calgary Herald)

Read about Mahfooz Kanwar’s critique of official multiculturalism in Canada:

About one dozen families who recently immigrated to Canada are demanding that the Louis Riel School Division in Winnipeg excuse their children from music and coed physical education programs for religious reasons.

The families believe that music is un-Islamic – just like the Taliban believe and then imposed on the entire population of Afghanistan – and that physical education classes should be segregated by gender even in the elementary years.

The school division is facing the music in a typically Canadian way – that is, bending itself into a trombone to try to accommodate these demands, even though in Manitoba, and indeed the rest of the country, music and phys. ed are compulsory parts of the curriculum.

Posted in Multiculturalism | 3 Comments

What Do Douglas Murray and Inayat Bunglawala Have In Common?

In a nutshell. On the position of “state multiculturalism” they are conjoined opposites who both betray liberal principles when they assert Islam, and the people who “adhere” (and I use that term in its loosest sense) to Islam, conform to a homogeneous and immutable religious identity, when it comes to the  issues of diversity of beliefs and equality of rights.

Kenan Malik draws their similarities in a nicely observed piece on the shared values of the anti-Multiculturalism camp and the pro-Multiculturalism camp, the Murrays and the Bunglawalas of the world, and how they are both wrong:

Posted in Multiculturalism | 7 Comments

Cameron Launches New Direction on Extremism

David Cameron unveils a new strategy in a speech today to tackle State Multiculturalism and how its policies have encouraged the growth of home-grown Islamist extremism in the UK. Cameron’s speech is not enough to counter extremism but it is at least a recognition of social policies that have enabled it to the flourish here in Britain, at taxpayers expense. It acknowldges the illiberal and intolerant views that we currently permit and refuse to challenge. Coming so soon after the Warsi debacle, this is a breath of fresh air.

The Independent:

In his speech, Mr Cameron rejected suggestions that a change in Western foreign policy could stop the Islamic terrorist threat and says Britain needs to tackle the home-grown causes of extremist ideology. “We have failed to provide a vision of society [to young Muslims] to which they feel they want to belong,” he said. “We have even tolerated segregated communities behaving in ways that run counter to our values. All this leaves some young Muslims feeling rootless. And the search for something to belong to and believe in can lead them to extremist ideology.”

Also posted in Identity Politics, Islamism | 4 Comments

When moderates take one step forward, Multiculturalism makes them take ten back

This is a guest post by Mr Happy


It always makes me uneasy when, instead of wiggling in their seats in our national legislatures, politicians decide to shimmy up to our most private and intimate spaces and order us how to think and react to topical issues.

They have no more virtue than you and I, no more experience in life or are any wiser but, essentially, this is what Baroness Warsi did a few weeks ago with her speech on ‘Islamophobia’.

I’m sure you followed the story but essentially the speech followed a line of anxiousness over Muslim integration and the problems associated. The most interesting part of the speech wasn’t that the Baroness placed the responsibility of Muslim integration mainly of Muslims (because she didn’t) but because her answer to the problems of ‘Islamophobia’ was to tell ordinary Britons that they should feel guilty when discussing Islam over the dinner table.

Posted in Multiculturalism | 1 Comment

Veiled Values

This is a cross-post by Kenan Malik


In his bestselling book America Alone, the Canadian writer Mark Steyn fantasises about the state of Europe in 2020. The Islamists have stormed to power right across the continent. No English pub can sell alcohol. Holland’s gay clubs have been relocated to San Francisco. And every French woman is forced to be veiled.

The fashion police, at least, have already arrived, a decade early and without any help from Islamists. But rather than forcing women to wear the burqa or niqab, their job is to force them not to. Earlier this month Italian police in the northern city of Novara fined a Tunisian immigrant, Amel Marmouri, €500 for being veiled in a post office. Belgian police are likely to be doing the same after the Brussels parliament outlawed the burqa. France expects to pass a similar law by the autumn. Holland could follow suit. The Spanish city of Lleida has forbidden the burqa in public buildings; the Minister of Labour and Immigration Celestino Corbacho has hinted at a national ban. In Canada, the Quebec government has drafted an anti-burqa law. Australian politicians are demanding one too.

Also posted in Anti Muslim bigotry, Fashion, Feminism, Freedom of Religion, Human Rights, Identity Politics, Islamism, Moral relativism, Secularism | 15 Comments

Is this the “counter-Enlightenment”?

i’ve not posted for a while, mostly because of pressure of work, but there are a number of things which are currently causing me to more or less lose sleep.

recently, i gave up posting on pickled politics, partly because of the level of personal animosity i was facing, but mostly just in frustration at my apparent inability to get my point across. now, i suppose i have nobody very much to blame for that apart from myself, but i’ve never felt that was a problem before now. now, i think i’m starting to work out what it is that is bothering me; certainly, it’s not about the denizens of one blog, or even the blogosphere, or even the media. it’s not any one set of views, not any one person, but a set of trends, a collective movement i sense in wider society.

Also posted in Anti Fascism, Anti Muslim bigotry, Antisemitism, Blogosphere, Christian Evangelical Nutters, Civil Rights, Democracy, Entryism, European Fascism, Freedom of Expression, Freedom of Religion, Human Rights, Identity Politics, Interfaith, Islamism, Jewish Extremism, Moral relativism, Obscurantism, Sectarianism, Secularism, The Far Left, The Regressive Left, UK Politics | 37 Comments
  • Categories

  • Archives