Hizb ut Tahrir implodes

This is a guest post by Shiraz Maher


Like the fruit of the medlar, Hizb ut Tahrir turned rotten long before it was ripe.

For years the group has boasted of inspiring a popular revolution on the Arab street and said it was in a position to ‘mould public opinion’ in favour of a Caliphate if only people would rise up against the regimes. Now that it’s finally happening, the party is nowhere to be seen in the Middle East.

Hizb ut Tahrir is failed and failing. But don’t just take my word for it.

For some time now I’ve been hearing of senior members defecting from the party in the UK. I wasn’t sure what to make of it but now I’ve had confirmation about some of the most significant departures over the last two years from a source still inside the party who is also preparing to leave. Recent significant departures include:

Farooq Khan* – Formerly on the national executive

Hasan Mujtaba – Formerly on the national executive

Asif Khan – Formerly on the national executive, formerly editor of Khilafah magazine (HT’s monthly), author of HT book on jurisprudence. You can read his book here (note that the editor listed on page 2 has also left the Hizb!)

Abid Husain – Formerly on the national executive,

Nadeem Ajayb – Regional director for Birmingham/West Midlands

Yusuf Patel – brother of Hizb ut Tahrir’s former British leader, Jalaluddin Patel

These are not the only serious defections, but they are the most significant ones in recent times. Since 2007, much of the Hizb’s middle management has also been decimated around the country. I’ve heard of – and met up with – countless erstwhile comrades around the country who once looked like they’d never leave the party. Now, they’re all realising life beyond.

The hizb’s problems extend way beyond defections. Internally, they’ve been suffering serious turbulence too. While he was still on the national executive, Farooq Khan, wrote to the party’s global leadership complaining about Jalaluddin Patel’s stewardship. He was rebuked as ‘arrogant’ and told to obey the amir – but the party investigated nonetheless. They dispatched Nasim Ghani from Bangladesh to investigate problems in the British chapter. In the event, Ghani failed to back Patel and he was then dismissed. Ghani stepped in as interim leader.

Then Asif Khan allegedly told other members he was resigning because of the cowardice of HT’s global leader Ata abu Rishta who is in hiding (and has been for many years). By contrast, Khan argued, Benazir Bhutto (for all her faults) had at least stood by her ideas and tried to affect public change in Pakistan. If she could demonstrate such commitment to her ideas – and die for them – then why should HT’s leader remain in hiding?

It reminds me of a trip I made to Pakistan in 2002 when I was with the Hizb. I wasn’t there on party business but I started hanging out with some of the members in Karachi – all of whom were from Britain. They complained that loads of guys from the UK had originally committed to moving to Pakistan telling them, “You go and we’re right behind you” but, when push came to shove, hardly any followed!

Farooq Khan and Asif Khan, along with Hasan Mujtaba and Abid Husain were all on the national executive when I became the first senior member to resign in 2005. At the time they organised the party’s machinery to discredit and crush me. Those were trying days, but I suspect they suffered no comparable indignity given just how many people are leaving the Hizb these days.

On a personal level, I’m sure those who played a hand in attacking me in 2005 will forgive me for being more than just a little smug about all this.

For leaving, I say ‘Ahlan wa Sahlan’ and dedicate this song to them:

My source in the party assures me he will leave soon. I can understand his hesitation, it can be difficult to take the final plunge. He’s speaking to others too. Another wave of defections could soon be on the cards. Watch this space.

*It should be stressed that I’ve not been able to confirm Farouq’s departure with my source. I heard from someone else that he’s left, but I’m not entirely certain about him, though I know for certain that he remains seriously disgruntled even if he has not yet departed.

This entry was posted in Islamism. Bookmark the permalink. Trackbacks are closed, but you can post a comment.


  1. Super Blue
    Posted June 19, 2011 at 6:15 PM | Permalink

    Neither of them will enjoy the comparison but the extremism, violence and discord of the Islamists reminds me of the BNP and the public problems Herr Griffin is having.

  2. Posted June 19, 2011 at 8:20 PM | Permalink

    Thanks Shiraz. This news is music to my ears.

  3. Wajid al-Icecreami
    Posted June 19, 2011 at 8:41 PM | Permalink

    Whether these guys leave or not HT is finished as a force within the British Muslim community and it was finished as a force in the middle east a long time ago. That is why they are focusing all their efforts of Australia and Canada these days, with limited success.

    There will always be some die hards that never leave (Fombo, Harwood et al) but anyone with half a brain has already left.

  4. Chuck
    Posted June 19, 2011 at 8:56 PM | Permalink

    What about Patrick Ghani?

  5. J'accuse
    Posted June 19, 2011 at 10:38 PM | Permalink

    This is all old news.

    Abid Hussain was never on the Wilayah Committee, in fact he was never even a member.

    All of them have been out of the party for at least three years, beside Yusef Patel, it’s more like one and a half years for him.

    If HT is such a spent force why bother writing about them, sour grapes?

  6. Abu Wannabe Arab
    Posted June 20, 2011 at 11:08 AM | Permalink

    Whenever a HTer leaves the party his seniority is always played down by HT propagandists, as if senior members never defect. HT is a spent force but that doesn’t mean we will stop talking about them, it’s too much fun watching the tragic demise of a cult that was on the verge of taking over the world 15 years ago.

  7. Chuck
    Posted June 20, 2011 at 11:34 AM | Permalink

    Yes yes, but what about Patrick Ghani?

  8. Sheikh Ya Buti
    Posted June 20, 2011 at 11:43 AM | Permalink

    Was Patrick Ghani the one who spent a few years sponging off the British Council in Bangladesh?

  9. Posted June 20, 2011 at 5:08 PM | Permalink

    you make it sound like an important organisation


    one might think that you were blowing smoke up your own arse


  10. adam
    Posted June 24, 2011 at 1:07 AM | Permalink
  11. fugstar
    Posted June 24, 2011 at 10:10 PM | Permalink

    from the point of view of terrorism at home and abroad, yes they can be dismissed.
    in fact they tend to be targets of state terror and games.

  12. smurfpower
    Posted June 25, 2011 at 12:35 AM | Permalink

    Poor HuT. My heart bleeds.

  13. Posted June 25, 2011 at 8:38 AM | Permalink

    Well, i think they are humans too

  14. Kisan
    Posted June 25, 2011 at 9:22 AM | Permalink

    Fugstar, whatever HuT is on the receiving end of is peanuts compared to what they will inflict on others if they gain their Caliphate where all politics other than theirs will be simply outlawed according to their constitution.

    Also, why a supposed liberal Sufi kind like yourself is shilling for the respectable arm of al Qaeda is disconcerting to those who would like to believe HuT are distorting Islam.

  15. M S
    Posted November 16, 2012 at 12:13 AM | Permalink

    Al hamdulillah , Allah swt filters the party all the time
    All the individuals that have left the party, obviously indicates that’s they shouldn’t be there in the first instance.
    I haven’t read they have a problem with ideas or the methods ,just all personal rubbish.
    And the big clean up has beenneeded in UK for a very long time .

  16. Posted January 13, 2013 at 11:17 PM | Permalink

    I’m sorry but I just spilt my tea over “Allah filters the party all the time” – HT owe me a new laptop dammitt!!!!!!

  17. Posted January 16, 2013 at 1:27 PM | Permalink

    Wishing HT all the best – our last chance before Britain becomes a de facto police state. Am I the sole one to notice the propaganda masquerading as “news” on Mali and Azawad?

  18. Kris
    Posted January 22, 2013 at 1:22 AM | Permalink

    Defection implies moving to an opposition group, therefore it is incorrect use of the word.
    Question, why do you ex-HT people take pride and smugness in your leaving HT, all you have demonstrated is you were certifiable morons for many years, the only difference, now, is that it is debatable.

Post a Comment

Your email is never published nor shared. Required fields are marked *


You may use these HTML tags and attributes <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>

Subscribe without commenting

  • Categories

  • Archives